This topic contains 10 replies, has 0 voices, and was last updated by  cbx550f 12 years, 5 months ago.

  • Author
    Posts
  • #3542

    Panther30
    Participant

    I think having lightning do damage to everything that is underwater when it strikes water would be a good idea. since electricty goes through water.

    —Panther30

    #19327

    BOY
    Participant

    that is quite simply the best idea I’ve heard of in a good while! I will add it to the feature request list 🙂 it is a great compromise for those that dont like movement into the water.

    #19328

    jdog
    Participant

    cool idea!

    #19329

    Panther30
    Participant

    @jdog wrote:

    cool idea!

    Inspired by nature.

    #19330

    guy parker
    Participant

    you might want to check the physics on that, i don’t think that it does equal damage to the whole water area when lightning hits, i think the damage would spread out from the point of contact. also, anyone in a small isolated “pool” of water created by explosions inland should not be affected by this, but i imagine the programming for that would be quite difficult.

    #19331

    badshot
    Participant

    Actually water conducts eletricity not that much better than ground. And actually how much lightning hurts depends to conductivity of medium around you in quite different way. For example, if you sit in steel shell, lighting will do zero damage to you, because steel conducts electricity well, and almost all current will go through steel and not through you. While in air (nonconductive except for lightning bolt) or on ground surface, if lightning hits you, _all current_ goes through you, and it really hurts.

    Indeed if there’s lot smaller voltages (e.g. 220v) , that’s whole different story (water helps to make good connection with skin).

    Also, I would expect inverse squares law to apply for underwater effects, as unlike air where you have small bolt where all current goes, in the sea current goes in all direction and if you’re far, not much through you.

    #19332

    cbx550f
    Participant

    Given that lightning is essentially a spark travelling between two conductors – really caused by the voltage potential exceeding the breakdown voltage of air (“normal” air has a breakdown voltage of about 30 kv/cm, IIRC), when lightning strikes water, it would tend to cease being lightning, and simply become a brief current flow until the potential difference has decreased to the point where it will no linger arc through the air.

    Having said that, what happens to a body that is in the water? Well, I would suggest that the same thing would happen to it that usually happens to aircraft that are struck: nothing. For example: Put a reasonably large metal tank (very conductive) in the water, completely submerged. Now, pass a current through the water, and what will happen to the tank? Well, the tank becomes a small part of the big conductor. Granted, the tank is MUCH more conductive than the water, so I would postulate that the tank would conduct more current than the water in its immediate vicinity, but still, the portion of the current that could pass through the tank would be miniscule compared to that which passes through the rest of the water.

    Point to ponder: When’s the last time you heard of a ship being sunk by lightning damage?

    #19333

    Willis
    Participant

    Well.. this is dating back to long ago but, as I recal pure water, Simple h2o, is not conductant very well or if at all. It is all the minerals and “debree” that give water its conductive attribute. Any science wizards wish to back or bash this?

    #19334

    DireWolf
    Participant

    Yes Willis you are correct, here is a link with an example of exactly what you are saying.
    http://scienceathome.cienciaviva.pt/conduti_agua_eng.html

    I have actually tried this with my kids for a school science project.

    but it is a cool idea!!!

    #19335

    cbx550f
    Participant

    Well, I’m assuming we are dealing with saltwater here (I think of the Scorched water as ocean), and it is “somewhat conductive”. (Moreso than freshwater, anyway)

    #19336

    Deathstryker
    Participant

    *ignores teacher and falls asleep*

    #19337

    cbx550f
    Participant

    @deathstryker wrote:

    *ignores teacher and falls asleep*

    ThWACK! Wake up!!

    rofl

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.